Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C. Profile & Reviews

View Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C. Reviews, Ratings and Testimonials

Law Firm in Madison, Wisconsin

Above Average 4

29 clients reviews

22 E Mifflin St #90, Madison, WI 53703

Personal Injury Catastrophic Injuries Litigation

Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C. Firm Reviews
4.0
29 reviews
Exceptional76%
Above Average0%
Mediocre0%
Poor0%
Substandard24%
4.0 out of 5 stars (based on 29 reviews)
John Shively
Submitted 
2026

Andrea Schoenherr (Winder) was a real life saver for me. I was going through the worst point in my life. She believed in me, backed me, and worked for me and got my life back. What more needs to be said.

Dave Curtis
Submitted 
2022
via Google

Very honest and reliable, which is particularly notable given the reputation attorneys have in general. The communication was always clear, straight-forward, and proactive. When I needed something explained, they were able to do so and I never had to prod for information. Given that it wasn’t exactly a choice to use an attorney’s office, I feel extraordinarily fortunate to have been represented by Nate and Jessa.

Bob Adler
Submitted 
2022
via Google

AVOID AT ALL COSTS. Every phone call and her nasally husband will charge you another $5000, Jessa will show up to court in flip-flops and cause more damage than good. She originally represented Kyle Rittenhouse and her lawyer, after the case was won, said that the turning point in the case was “getting rid of the original representation.” Couldn’t agree more, same for me! James was rude, condescending, and unprofessional. Basically think of the guy at the front door of the castle of the Wizard of Oz, or the French guy on the roof in the castle scene of Monty Python and the Holy Grail. Snotty, rude, callous, and will charge you a FORTUNE. What a LOSER! On the surface, the team seems competent, but be warned. They will bungle your case and leave you penniless. This office cost me $10,000 and left me worse off than when I began!! The best decision I made was changing lawyers halfway through the case! This may sound harsh but I’d rather them get a dose of my opinion than you make the same mistake I did! AVOID AVOID AVOID!!!! I’D GIVE A NEGATIVE 20 STAR REVIEW IF I COULD! Edit: They claim they never represented me but they did. I am just not gonna put my real name for a dirty lawyer to run with. How else would I be able to provide all these details? Further, what I am saying is corroborated (nice lawyer speak eh?) with several other reviews. Enjoy this poor review like you represented me so poorly, hopefully it costs you a couple clients! Reap as you sow!

Compare Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C. With These Top Law Firms

View Morgan & Morgan Reviews, Ratings and Testimonials
Accidents Animal Attacks Bicycle Accidents Birth Injuries Brain Injuries Bus Accidents Car Accidents Catastrophic Injuries Chemical Hair Relaxers Class Actions Dog Bites Drowning Accidents Earplugs - 3M Firefighting Foam Lawsuit Johnson’s Talcum Powder Junk Food Childhood Diabetes Lawsuit Litigation Lyft Accidents Medical Malpractice Motorcycle Accidents NEC Infant Formula Lawsuit Neck Injuries Nursing Home Neglect Pain & Suffering Paragard Lawsuit Paraquat Lawsuit Pedestrian Accidents Personal Injury PFAS Forever Chemicals Property Insurance Claims Roundup Slip & Fall Social Media Harm Social Security Disability Truck Accidents Uber Accidents Weight Loss & Diabetes Drug Lawsuits Wrongful Death
All 50 States
(866) 549-2161 Free consultation
View Alexander Shunnarah Trial Attorneys Reviews, Ratings and Testimonials
Accidents Animal Attacks Bicycle Accidents Birth Injuries Boating Accidents Bodily Injuries Brain Injuries Burn Injuries Bus Accidents Car Accidents Catastrophic Injuries Class Actions Construction Accidents Defective Products Dog Bites Drowning Accidents Earplugs - 3M Employment Law Hernia Mesh Junk Food Childhood Diabetes Lawsuit Lyft Accidents Medical Malpractice Motorcycle Accidents Neck Injuries Nursing Home Neglect Pain & Suffering Paragard Lawsuit Paraquat Lawsuit Pedestrian Accidents Personal Injury Premises Liability Property Insurance Claims Roundup Slip & Fall Social Security Disability Toxic Torts Truck Accidents Uber Accidents Workers' Compensation Workplace Injuries Wrongful Death
All 50 States
(866) 725-4582 Free consultation
View Kmiec Law Offices Reviews, Ratings and Testimonials
Accidents Animal Attacks Boating Accidents Brain Injuries Car Accidents Catastrophic Injuries Construction Accidents Disability Benefits Dog Bites Litigation Medical Malpractice Neck Injuries Personal Injury Premises Liability Slip & Fall Truck Accidents Workers' Compensation Workplace Injuries Wrongful Death
3741 W National Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53215
Read reviews
Find Your Elite Litigator
×